|
|
Post by TheEnhancedOne on Mar 16, 2016 22:49:23 GMT
So at first you may think a feeder is a good thing, however, from experience I have learnt better. I will try to make the most unbiased Pros vs Cons table as possible. Opposing arguments are welcome to this thread. | Pros | Cons | | 100 people in the clan (Growth of the clan) | Causes jealousy/hatred among feeder clan and main clan. | | Gives an incentive to lower players to want to get to the main clan | Main Clan members may want to visit feeder often which will impact clan trophies and our goal for top 200. | | Don't have to keep kicking players | The thrive to get to the main clan will diminish once they find other clans that are better than the feeder but not better than the main clan/ Other clans will send members to the feeder to recruit. | | Allows casual gameplay. | Why does sleds alt get to run? arguements.. name arguements.. democrahit or dictatorship 2? | Encourage players to sign up to this forum to make communication easier.
| Hard to run 2 clans at once. |
| Make tournaments and chatting more complicated |
|
|
|
|
Post by THE SLED HAMMER on Mar 16, 2016 22:56:27 GMT
Your cons (when I number mine I'm referring to your points that aren't numbered ex: 'Causes jealously/hatred among feeder and main clan' my rebuttal for that will be 1.)
1. Be more specific on that, honestly that makes no sense with no prior knowledge
2. Why the hell will people want to visit the feeder? The feeder will be trash anyway tbh + most of us top players that WOULD impact our trophies if they wanted to visit have alts they could visit with.
3. The whole goal of the feeder is to get people welcome to the atmosphere of our clan chain and make sure they are comfortable with how most of us are before joining the main clan. Even if your thoughts were 'they join feeder for TROPHY reasons' I get that the only reason we have a feeder is for people with not enough trophies, but like a just said it sets and keeps the same atmosphere of the main clan since most people getting kicked from the main clan for the feeder are used to our environment which helps a player with being nice and saying the right things in the clan.
4. They'd probably do that to the main clan if they want GOOD members, and we havent gotten any of those so why the hell would other clans want the bottom of the barrel?
|
|
|
|
Post by TheEnhancedOne on Mar 16, 2016 23:02:35 GMT
1. to be specific, jealousy will be among players in the feeder due to not getting into the main clan etc.., also this links to my point of why your alt gets to lead.
2. People will want to visit the feeder not because its good but because they want to help it grow (players with higher trophies such as neloshan will make the feeder more attractive)
3. Clan chain will only form if we have an audience (being in the top 200 or being a youtuber/streamer) basically a clash royale celebrity. Why would people be invested in joining the B clan?
4. They would do that to our main clan but our main clan is what the feeder clan members will be thriving for. They arent thriving to stay at the feeder so they will be more likely to be disloyal to the feeder than to the main.
|
|
|
|
Post by THE SLED HAMMER on Mar 16, 2016 23:09:24 GMT
1. They are in the feeder because they don't have enough trophies they are literally incapable of joining the main clan, joining the feeder gets them better chance of getting in
2. I get what your saying, but we aren't really trying to make the clan look GOOD it's just that we want kicked members or low trophy players to have somewhere to GO if they want to get in the main clan
3. By chain I mean 2 clans, like I've said over 9000 times the players invest in the feeder to have better chances of joining the A clan
4. THE FEEDER MEMBERS WILL BE THRIVING TO GET IN THE DAMN MAIN CLAN! Sorry, its too obvious. The will be disloyal but that lowers their chances of staying in the main clan
Basically what I'm getting at is the feeder is purely for players too low on trophies and want to get in the main clan, if people get in the main clan from the feeder even if they are the bottom player deserve to stay in the clan atleast for a bit since they stuck it out in the feeder, if they came out of nowhere and are the lowest player when we're full the should get kicked if they are just a lowly member with nothing to help us. People staying in the feeder that get transferred to the main should be respected and should stay in the clan even as the lowest player.
|
|
|
|
Post by TheEnhancedOne on Mar 16, 2016 23:15:01 GMT
1. I guess that makes sense but then when someone joins the feeder, be honest to them and say you have a 99% chance of not joining the main clan and see how quickly they leave.
2. Ok so then we will have to discourage our main clan players from ever going to the feeder
3. Same kinda thing as I said in my first point and besides the feeder will have little to no exposure and will be hard to recruit for the feeder.
4. I agree with this.
I think we will have to have a little democracy in this dictatorship clan and have a poll on whether to have a feeder or not.
|
|
|
|
Post by THE SLED HAMMER on Mar 16, 2016 23:19:13 GMT
1. Yea I get it but being loyal and staying in the feeder through thick and then gets them better chances of staying in the main clan longer than if they came outta nowhere
2. This makes sense
3. Well it is a casual clan so any members we kick out of the main we can have a msg saying 'join the damn feeder Dictatorship 2'
4. Its settled then
Yea we need all the member's opinions esp co's (yay for democracy Bernie4president)
|
|
